Medical examiner defends ‘excited delirium’ in Nekeya Moody death trial
At a Ramsey County trial over the 2020 death of Nekeya Moody, the county medical examiner has defended listing “excited delirium” as the cause of death, saying the condition stemmed from cocaine use and exertion rather than from asphyxia related to restraint. Moody died after deputies responded to a mental‑health call; her family has filed a federal civil‑rights lawsuit and attorneys and activists have said the case centers on whether deputies used excessive force or failed to provide adequate care during her crisis.
The contested diagnosis is part of a broader pattern: between 2010 and 2020 there were at least 166 reported deaths in police custody in which excited delirium was cited, and studies of those cases show the label has disproportionately involved Black and Latinx people—about 56% of such deaths despite those groups making up roughly 31% of the U.S. population. More broadly, Black Americans are killed by police at higher rates than White Americans (about 6 per million annually versus roughly 2.5 per million), a disparity that civil‑rights advocates say makes diagnoses like excited delirium especially fraught in deaths following detention or restraint.
Public reaction has been vocal on social media and among advocacy groups: family members, attorneys and activists have pushed for accountability and criticized the Ramsey County Sheriff’s Office for its handling of the call and for personnel decisions involving the deputies. At the same time, local outlets such as FOX9 and community reporting have highlighted the medical examiner’s defense of the diagnosis. That tension reflects a larger shift in mainstream coverage — earlier reporting more readily accepted excited delirium as a medical explanation, while more recent scrutiny, amplified after events like Ferguson and George Floyd and driven by local investigative reporting, activists and civil‑rights litigation, increasingly questions the diagnosis and highlights racial and policing disparities.
📊 Relevant Data
From 2010 to 2020, at least 56% of police custody deaths attributed to excited delirium involved Black and Latinx individuals, who comprise approximately 31% of the US population.
Excited Delirium — Virginia Law Review
Between 2010 and 2020, there were at least 166 reported deaths in police custody where excited delirium was cited as a cause or significant factor in the death.
Excited Delirium — Virginia Law Review
Black Americans are killed by police at a rate of about 6 per million people annually, compared to about 2.5 per million for White Americans, based on data from 2015 to 2024.
Police shootings database 2015-2024 — The Washington Post
In 2019, Black individuals accounted for 51.3% of arrests for murder and nonnegligent manslaughter in the US, despite comprising about 13% of the population, while White individuals accounted for 45.7%.
Crime in the United States 2019 - Table 43 — FBI Uniform Crime Reporting
📌 Key Facts
- Moody died days after a February 2020 encounter with Ramsey County deputies in which she was restrained prone during a mental‑health call and later tested positive for alcohol and cocaine at the ER.
- Medical examiner Dr. Butch Huston testified for the defense that her cause of death was “excited delirium,” said he ruled out asphyxia, and insisted the deputies’ prone restraint did not cause her death.
- A plaintiff expert on law‑enforcement best practices said deputies failed to follow guidance such as sitting Moody up after she lost consciousness, while a defense expert said the deputies’ actions met best‑practice standards.
- “Excited delirium” is not recognized by the American Medical Association, making its use in this case controversial and part of a broader national debate over policing and in‑custody death diagnoses.
- The civil lawsuit, brought by Moody’s family against Ramsey County and two deputies for alleged civil and constitutional rights violations, is ongoing with the deputies scheduled to testify next.
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time